Original Udder Balm vs Bag Balm: What’s the Difference?
If you’ve ever searched for heavy-duty skin care, you’ve probably come across both Original Udder Balm and Bag Balm. Some people think they are the same thing, but they are very different. These two products share a common history in farming, but over the years they’ve taken very different paths. Both are trusted names, yet they’re not the same — and depending on your skin care needs, one may be a better fit for you.
A Quick History
-
Original Udder Balm was developed in the 1970s as a moisturizer for dry, cracked skin, both on the farm and at home. It has been produced in the U.S. for decades by a family-owned company committed to safe, simple, and effective skincare.
-
Bag Balm, first introduced in 1899, was originally designed for soothing cow udders. It is still produced by a Vermont-based company and sold in its signature green tin.
Ingredient Comparison: Original Udder Balm vs Bag Balm
| Feature | Original Udder Balm | Bag Balm |
|---|---|---|
| Base formula | Water-based cream with mineral oil, lanolin, glycerin, aloe vera, and vitamins A, D, and E | Petrolatum (petroleum jelly) + lanolin |
| Extras | Aloe vera, sorbitol, vitamin blend | Antiseptic (8-hydroxyquinoline sulfate) |
| Fragrance | Light lemon scent (since 1970s) or unscented/dye-free option | Unscented |
| Additives | No harsh detergents, no SLS, no formaldehyde, no phthalates | Simple ointment, but antiseptic makes it less cosmetic and more medicinal |
Bag Balm™ is a registered trademark of Dairy Association Co., Inc. Product image used here for comparison purposes only. Original Udder Balm® is not affiliated with Bag Balm™.